Microsoft OneDrive Review & Rating
OneDrive is Microsoft’s answer to Apple’s iCloud and Google Drive. Well, that’s not entirely accurate, since OneDrive actually preceded those cloud file storage and syncing services by at least five years, albeit under various other names like SkyDrive, Live Mesh, and FolderShare. OneDrive’s functionality and design have morphed to a point of slick usability and reliability, with a rich feature set, online office apps, and wide platform support. OneDrive sports attractive web and mobile interfaces, music streaming, photo AI, real-time coediting, and powerful search. The service’s deep integration with Windows 10 and Office 365 and its completeness, maturity, and polish earn it not only an Editors’ Choice award, but also a rare 5-star rating.
Microsoft’s online backup and syncing service offers syncing and access apps not only for PCs, but also for Macs, Androids, iOS, and Xbox. It integrates seamlessly with Microsoft Office (both the installed and online versions) and includes rich photo presentations, too. Apple’s competing iCloud is only available for Apple devices. And while iCloud Drive and Google Drive now make stuff stored in their cloud services available on the web, OneDrive tops that by even making PC files that you didn’t specifically upload available.
Like iCloud and Google Drive, OneDrive serves a lot of functions. If you just want access to documents or media files, it offers simple online storage accessible from the web. If you want the same set of files replicated on multiple PCs, it provides folder syncing. For Windows 10 users, it backs up device settings, including things like lock-screen and desktop-background images and browser favorites. It also syncs Office documents and enables co-authoring.
Because of this diversity of functions, there are a few different cross-sections from which you can view the service—by type of data, client, or function. The data types include documents, photos, video, music, or settings. The clients include computer, mobile, and web, and the functions are things like syncing, viewing, playing, and simple storage. Let’s take a look at the service from these various angles.
Your OneDrive Account
Anyone with a Microsoft account can get a free OneDrive account; that includes everyone who’s ever signed up for a Hotmail, Live, Office 365, or Outlook.com account. Free users get 5GB free storage space, but if you’re a longtime OneDrive account holder (since April 21, 2012, or earlier), you get an extra 10GB free. This compares with 1GB free for iCloud, 2GB for Dropbox, and 15GB for Google Drive.
Office 365 users get an extra terabyte with their $6.99-per-month subscription, along with more features like expiring and password-protected share links and ransomware protection, not to mention downloadable Office programs. Another option is to add 50GB of storage to OneDrive for $1.99 per month, though you lose the just-mentioned benefits. You can get more free storage through referrals—500MB for each friend you get to sign up. Here’s a summary of the pricing compared with that of top competitors:
Device Syncing Microsoft likes to refer to OneDrive as a “device cloud.” With Windows 10 PCs and Windows Phones, the buzzphrase makes sense. The service can sync settings and apps on those types of devices, while clients for iOS, Android, and MacOS give users of those devices access to the files stored in OneDrive’s online folders.
Like iCloud for iPhones and iPads, OneDrive lets smartphone users—with iPhones or Androids running the service’s app as well as Windows Phones—automatically upload photos (and videos) taken with the phone’s camera to OneDrive’s camera roll. This way, the photos are quickly available for viewing online, in a OneDrive folder on a PC, in a Windows 10 PC’s Photos app, on the web, or in any other OneDrive app you have installed.
Settings syncing Another service in the realm of device syncing is the ability to sign into your account and reproduce a previous machine you’ve set up—color and background themes, social and email accounts, user photo, browser favorites and history, and even apps. OneDrive accomplishes this for both Windows 8.x and Windows 10 PCs and Windows Phones. But the service goes even further, by allowing third-party apps to take advantage of your cloud storage. Apps and sites can even use the service for single sign-on with your permission.
Folder and File Syncing OneDrive offers another desktop computer-centric function—file and folder syncing. This convenience is similar to what you get with Dropbox and SugarSync. In the past, Microsoft had separate storage and syncing services. The joining of online storage and syncing into one cloud service is a refreshing simplification of a previously somewhat confusing set of systems.
OneDrive syncing on computers differs from the earlier Mesh and from Sugarsync in that you can’t designate any old folder you want to be synced, only those under the OneDrive main folder. But Microsoft has made it possible for these synced folders to look less sequestered in the OneDrive world, by using Windows’ Libraries. It also adds a truly cool feature called Fetch—more about that in a moment.
The desktop clients for OneDrive syncing run on Windows 10, Windows 8/8.1, Windows 7, and Apple macOS 10.10 or later. They’re quick to install, with a setup wizard that lets you create an account if you don’t already have one. It then shows how your OneDrive folder will appear in Windows Explorer (or Finder), with its little blue cloud icon instead of the traditional yellow folder icon. Setup also places a cloud icon in your system tray, from which you can open your synced folder or change settings.
When you place a photo, document, or other item in the created OneDrive folder, it automatically appears in any of your other OneDrive clients on any of your other computers. You can even share a whole folder, but to coedit documents in the online versions of Office applications you have to share individual files. As noted above, paid OneDrive users can password-protect shared files as well as set expiration times for them. Apple and Google’s cloud services don’t offer either at any plan level.
For a quick test of cross-platform syncing, I installed OneDrive on both an iMac and a Windows desktop. I then created a new folder in the OneDrive app, which appeared a couple seconds later in the Mac’s OneDrive folder. Including OneDrive in Windows Explorer is incredibly helpful because you can save work from any application to your cloud storage directly, without having to go to a website. That includes apps that autosave files. I should note, however that Apple’s Windows desktop utility for iCloud Drive and Google Drive’s Backup and Sync utility let you do this, too.
Files on Demand
One of the greatest things to ever happen to OneDrive was Windows 10 Fall Creators Update’s implementation of Files on Demand. With this enabled from OneDrive’s Settings panel, you no longer have to fill every connected computer’s drive with every file stored in the OneDrive cloud. Instead, as the name implies, the files are only downloaded on-demand as you open them.
You can still designate folder and files to be downloaded for offline use; a new column in File Explorer called Status shows a cloud icon for online files and folders, and a circled check mark for items stored locally. Files waiting to be uploaded sport a circular-arrows icon. In my usage, the feature works flawlessly. Google subsequently unveiled a similar capability, though only for G Suite customers, with File Stream. Apple’s iCloud Drive still has no on-demand capability for its Windows client, but works on-demand by default for Macs and iOS devices. Conversely, Files on Demand is not available in the Mac OneDrive client.
With Windows 10, OneDrive is more of a built-in capability. You see OneDrive in the File Explorer, and you can choose which OneDrive folders are synced or have everything synced. Results in Cortana searches for files now include OneDrive files, and the Groove Music app can still stream any music files you upload to OneDrive (though it no longer offers a paid music streaming subscription service).
I’ve already mentioned the availability of Android and iOS apps for OneDrive, but Mobile apps for OneDrive have even made the jump beyond the smartphone: Apple Watch Series 3 and Android Wear versions are now available, which let you do things like cycle through recent photos on the watch face. Tablets running iOS, Windows 10, and Android can also take advantage of OneDrive apps, and failing that, there’s always the excellent web interface.
The mobile apps let you not only view anything stored up in your OneDrive, but also upload photos and share anything stored via the cloud to anyone with an email address or Facebook account. They can even show photos grouped by autogenerated tag subjects like #people, #animal, #building, and so on.
I tried out mobile access to OneDrive on my iPhone X and an Android Samsung Galaxy Note 8. The OneDrive apps are nicely designed, clearly showing your cloud folders, and even letting your view photos and documents (even spreadsheets and PDFs) within the app. They also let you share anything in the folders via an email link (with view only or edit permissions), or to copy items to the phone’s cut-and-paste clipboard. You can now also designate files for offline viewing and editing.
Happily, Microsoft has added a search capability to the mobile apps. All of the mobile apps also now let you automatically upload any photos (and optionally videos) shot on the device using the Automatically Upload to OneDrive option. You can watch videos on the phone, too. One cool thing is the ability to upload photos from the iPhone’s camera roll or other galleries, marking multiple folders for upload. But the fetch feature to find any files on the PC signed into the same OneDrive account isn’t available in the mobile clients.
Another OneDrive option for mobile users is the collection of Office Mobile apps—Word Mobile, Excel Mobile, PowerPoint Mobile, and OneNote. These are available for Android, iOS, and Windows 10 (both desktop and mobile), and on the web. In fact, the web version of OneDrive offers a big dropdown menu of tiles for all these online apps. Documents you create in these are be automatically synced to all your OneDrive access points.
OneDrive on the Web and Fetch
OneDrive on the web is linked with other Microsoft online services through a top switcher menu that includes Mail (either Outlook.com or Hotmail), People (the social network-aggregator app), and Calendar. The site offers easy access to all your OneDrive-stores documents and media. It’s a very fast and clean interface, with a left panel of menu choices including Files, Recent docs, Shared, Groups, and PCs.
That last item may be the most interesting: For PCs you’ve installed the desktop client on and authorized, you can pull any files using Fetch, even if the files aren’t in the OneDrive folder. When I chose the PCs option from the web interface’s left rail, I was greeted by a message saying “Security check! To connect to this PC we need you to enter a security code. This extra step only takes a minute and will help protect your computer from unauthorized access.” When I clicked the “Sign in with security code” link and completed a partial email address, an email to an associated address was sent with a code.
Once I jumped all the security hurdles, I could browse the entire disk of my target PC. I could download any files found there, or upload them to OneDrive (which feels a little odd, since it seemed like I was browsing OneDrive). I could also view all the files’ pertinent properties in a right-side panel—type, size, and dates created and modified. The Fetch feature is a great idea, though it seems to be only available in a very limited set of circumstances. You’re probably better off just saving files you think you may need remote access to your OneDrive cloud folders.
Microsoft’s cloud service plays and displays all the most common types of files you might want to store in the cloud, including documents, music, photos, and video. Here’s a rundown of how each is handled:
Documents Not only can you download and upload document files, as you can with iCloud’s web interface, you can actually view and edit them online with OneDrive using the integrated Office Online apps. In fact, OneDrive serves as the main folder and file location for all your Office Online documents, just as Google Drive does for Google Docs. Just as in Google Docs, multiple authors can edit documents at the same time. An icon shows who’s typing where, and the document contents are updated live. Office Online also offers better document-formatting fidelity than you get with Docs.
I had no problem viewing Microsoft file formats like Word Documents, Excel spreadsheets, and PowerPoint presentations using the online Office apps. I could also view PDFs, and Windows knew to open a ZIP file on the desktop, showing the archive’s contents in a folder. Office 365 applications have OneDrive baked in, too, as the default save location. This is pretty convenient when you want to work on a file at home that you started at work.
Music Windows 10’s music-playing ap Groove, lets you stream any songs you upload to OneDrive. The iTunes in the Cloud piece of the iCloud service performs this feat for Apple devices and computers, while Google Play Music does so for Android users. OneDrive’s web version can also play songs directly, but, unlike the installed Groove app on Windows 10, it can’t play FLAC lossless music files. (The Xbox Groove app has that same limitation, unfortunately, since home theater users could benefit from it.)
Photos and Video OneDrive does an impressive job of displaying photos and videos in its web interface. It even auto-tags images using AI the way Flickr does, grouping, for example, all photos of dogs, crowds, or buildings by tag. This makes searching more powerful, since you can narrow results down by either type of tag. Google Photos offers similar search capability, though without explicitly showing you the tags. Both of those services also let you see a map of where the photo was taken (if it’s geotagged, as most smartphone photos are now) and EXIF camera data. Apple iCloud doesn’t have any search, tagging, or EXIF display at all. You can share and tag photos by yourself, too, and when you do share, unlike in the past, the recipient doesn’t have to sign into a Microsoft account. You can also specify read and edit rights.
When you share a video from OneDrive, the cloud service transcodes it on the fly using MPEG-DASH to match the capabilities of the receiver’s bandwidth. This way if you share to someone’s phone, he or she won’t download an unnecessarily large file that would be prone to pause the video for buffering. I tried sharing a video to a phone with just three bars of LTE connectivity, and my test movie played smoothly and clearly without interruption.
OneDrive also includes OCR, which extracts text from images. If you save a photo with text in it to your cloud storage, the Info panel on its OneDrive page includes an extracted text area, which you can click to cut and paste anywhere. Google Drive’s help talks about OCR, but I couldn’t find it in the live service; perhaps it’s another casualty of feature culling. And forget any OCR in iCloud or Dropbox.
Using OneDrive With Windows UWP Apps
The UWP (Universal Windows Platform, or modern Store app) version of OneDrive for Windows 10 is somewhat redundant, not really offering anything you can’t do in File Explorer or on the website. One capability is does add is to make OneDrive a share target in the standard UWP app Share panel. It’s a perfectly functional utility for viewing and uploading folders and files, and it looks good, especially in dark mode. I can also see how it would be useful for Windows tablet users and those few remaining Windows Phone users.
Any Windows modern-style UWP app can take advantage of OneDrive cloud storage, though. Microsoft has made it really simple for developers to do this. For example, the FotoEditor app, a sort of Instagram without the social networking, let me save my filtered image to OneDrive. It also let me open photos for editing from my cloud folders. We should see more extensive use of OneDrive in third-party apps as the Window Store fills out, particularly those that need to use app state and settings syncing.
One Place in the Cloud for Your Digital Life
Microsoft’s cloud solution has come together admirably in OneDrive, combining file syncing with cloud storage. Cross-platform support for Android, iOS, macOS, and Xbox devices is a smart move on Microsoft’s part, too. That’s not to say that there aren’t other great choices out there, however; Editors’ Choice Google Drive is also an excellent service, especially for those who are committed to Google’s online ecosystem and for its more-generous 15GB free storage. Box, another PCMag Editors’ Choice, excels in third-party service integration.
But OneDrive is the only cloud service that lets you fetch any file from a PC you’ve set up and the only major platform’s cloud that lets you set passwords and expiration dates for shared files. Its integration with Office and third-party apps, on-demand folder syncing, and multitude of platform options including a top-notch web interface and productivity apps earn Microsoft OneDrive a five-star PCMag top Editors’ Choice for cloud storage and syncing, nudging it past the also-excellent Editors’ Choice Google Drive by a nose.
For more how to get the most out of the service, you can read our story on how to manage, sync, and share files in Microsoft OneDrive.